I review a lot of books. Most of them are pretty good (my editors pre-sort, and yes, they do read them before they assign them), and a few of them turn out to be great. Here's my list of favorite books of 2011. Some of them came out prior to 2011. One probably won't get popular until early 2012. Most of them I didn't review, I just happened to come upon them in the library or the bookstore or got sent an early copy in one of those padded mailers that pile up on our porch. What's my opinion worth? I'll let this gentleman from Frisbee: A Book Journal answer that question. "Bruce Barcott, a contributing editor at Outside Magazine, enjoyed and admired [insert author's name here]'s book. But do I know Bruce Barcott? Heavens, no. He might have good taste, or he might not."
Fair enough, Frisbee.
MY 5 FAVORITE BOOKS OF 2011:
5. Room For Improvement: Notes on a Dozen Lifelong Sports, by John Casey. Surprising, lovely, plainspoken essays and memoirs about the pleasures of exercise throughout a long and productive life.
4. No Cheating, No Dying, by Elizabeth Weil. You may have read her recent profile of Diana Nyad in the NYT Magazine, or the excerpt from this book in the NYTM in 2010. She's a delightful writer, married to my Outside Mag compatriot Dan Duane. This one should be hitting bookstores in a week or two. Great book about Gen X marriage, trials, tribulations, annoyances, and the quest for improvement.
3. Please Kill Me: The Uncensored Oral History of Punk, by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain. I ran across a copy of this old classic (originally published in 1996) at a book fair in Brazil in October. It's still as good as you remember. Simply the best oral history published in my lifetime. Incredible research, depth, interviews, and brilliant editing.
2. The Better Angels of our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined, by Steven Pinker. The year's most thought-provoking book, and one that quite improved my outlook on the human condition. If you like Jared Diamond, you'll love this book.
1. The Marriage Plot, by Jeffrey Eugenides. My reading runs heavily to nonfiction, and I wasn't a big fan of Eugenides' previous novels. But this one swept me away. Absolutely genius writing, perfect evocation of college life in the eighties, all wrapped up with a satisfying and spectacularly spot-on finish.
THE MOST DISAPPOINTING BOOK OF 2011:
1. Those Guys Have All the Fun, Tom Shales' oral history of ESPN. Shales' Saturday Night Live book was a hoot. And I'm a total ESPN junkie. I'll even watch Colin Cowherd on Sports Nation. Really. But this book was a complete piece of crap. Expectation: Pages of amusing anecdotes on Chris Berman, memories of Aussie rules football and Super Bowl parties. Delivered: Page after page of boring BS on the network's owners, whine whine whine about what a craptown Bristol is, Keith Olbermann's an ass, that NFL drama series sucked, the magazine succeeded, and did I mention what an ass Keith Olbermann is? I threw it across the room in disgust when some ESPN reporter started getting all proud about scooping the world with news of the Danny Tartabull trade. Way to go, fellah. There's a classic scene in one of the earliest episodes of Homicide: Life on the Street where Det. Munch (the great Richard Belzer) slaps around a suspect who's holding out on him. Munch: "Whatta you, saving your best stories for Montel Williams? Is that it? You saving the good stuff for Montel Williams?" This book felt like everyone who'd ever worked at ESPN was saving their best stories for Montel Williams.
GREATEST GUILTY PLEASURE OF 2011:
1. The Book of Basketball, by Bill Simmons. Yes, I am the last man in America to read this book. I picked up the paperback for like $3.99 at a Borders that was going out of business over on Kauai. And devoured the thing. It was like text cocaine. I could not stop. Yes! Tell me more about Artis Gilmore! And David Thompson! Or is it Mychal Thompson? I don't care, just don't stop writing about basketball, Bill Simmons!